Jeep Cherokee Pickup For Sale: Unearthing the Rugged Charm of the Comanche MJ

Jeep Cherokee Pickup For Sale: Unearthing the Rugged Charm of the Comanche MJ typestruckssale.com

In the vast landscape of classic American automobiles, few vehicles strike a chord quite like the Jeep Cherokee Pickup, more commonly known as the Jeep Comanche (MJ). This unique blend of the beloved XJ Cherokee’s robustness with the utility of a pickup bed has cultivated a dedicated following, making it a highly sought-after vehicle for enthusiasts, off-roaders, and collectors alike. If you’re looking for a vehicle that combines legendary Jeep capability with practical hauling power and a healthy dose of retro cool, then a Jeep Cherokee Pickup for sale might just be your ultimate find. This comprehensive guide will navigate you through everything you need to know about acquiring one of these iconic machines.

Quick Read show

The Legend of the Comanche (MJ): A Brief History

Jeep Cherokee Pickup For Sale: Unearthing the Rugged Charm of the Comanche MJ

Produced from 1986 to 1992, the Jeep Comanche (MJ) was an innovative move by AMC (and later Chrysler) to capture a slice of the compact pickup truck market. Unlike traditional body-on-frame pickups, the Comanche shared its unibody construction with the wildly popular XJ Cherokee SUV, from the cab forward. This gave it a more car-like ride and handling while maintaining impressive off-road prowess. It was available with various engine options, including the reliable 2.5L AMC I4 and the much-revered 4.0L AMC straight-six, the latter of which cemented its reputation for durability and power. Offered in both short (6-foot) and long (7-foot) bed configurations, and with 2WD or Command-Trac/Selec-Trac 4WD systems, the Comanche was surprisingly versatile. Though its production run was relatively short, the MJ left an indelible mark, evolving into a cult classic due to its unique design, rugged dependability, and a distinct character that sets it apart from other pickups of its era.

Why Buy a Jeep Cherokee Pickup (Comanche)?

The decision to purchase a Comanche goes beyond simple utility; it’s an embrace of a unique automotive philosophy. Here are several compelling reasons why these pickups remain highly desirable:

Unmatched Durability & Reliability: The 4.0L inline-six engine is legendary for its longevity and ability to withstand abuse. Properly maintained, these engines can easily exceed 300,000 miles, making the Comanche a truly dependable workhorse.
Legendary Off-Road Capability: Inheriting the XJ Cherokee’s DNA, the Comanche boasts excellent ground clearance, robust axles, and effective 4WD systems, making it incredibly capable on trails, in mud, or over rocky terrain.
Practicality Meets Compact Size: It offers the utility of a pickup bed without the cumbersome footprint of a full-size truck, making it maneuverable in urban environments while still capable of hauling gear, lumber, or even a dirt bike.
Classic Status & Collector’s Item: With relatively low production numbers compared to the XJ Cherokee, the Comanche is becoming increasingly rare and sought after. Well-preserved examples are appreciating in value, making them a potential investment.
Customization Potential: The shared XJ platform means a vast aftermarket exists for suspension lifts, armor, performance upgrades, and aesthetic modifications, allowing owners to tailor their Comanche to their specific needs and tastes.
Distinctive Style: Its unibody design with a separate bed gives it a unique profile that stands out from more conventional pickups. It possesses an undeniable vintage charm that appeals to many.

Key Considerations When Searching for a Jeep Cherokee Pickup For Sale

Finding the right Comanche requires careful consideration of several factors. Given their age, condition varies widely.

Rust is the Enemy: This is arguably the most critical factor. Inspect the frame rails, floorboards, rocker panels, bed mounts, and wheel wells thoroughly. Rust can compromise structural integrity and be very costly to repair. Pay special attention to the rear "frame" area where the bed attaches.
Engine & Drivetrain: The 4.0L I6 is preferred for power and reliability. Check for oil leaks, strange noises, and smooth operation. Test both 2WD and 4WD (high and low range). Automatic (AW4) and manual (AX-15) transmissions are both robust, but ensure smooth shifts and no slipping.
Mileage vs. Maintenance: High mileage isn’t necessarily a deal-breaker for a 4.0L, provided it has a documented history of regular maintenance. Conversely, a low-mileage example with no records could be problematic.
Trim Levels & Options: Comanches came in various trims like Eliminator, Pioneer, Chief, Sportruck, and Custom. Eliminators are generally the most desirable with sportier styling and more features. Bed length (short or long box) and 2WD vs. 4WD will significantly impact utility and resale value.
Modifications: Assess any modifications. A well-executed lift kit with quality components can be a plus, but poorly installed lifts or excessive "bubba" modifications can indicate neglect or underlying issues. Look for balanced upgrades rather than just giant tires.
Documentation: Service records, previous owner history, and a clean title are invaluable. They provide insight into the vehicle’s past and indicate responsible ownership.

Where to Find a Jeep Cherokee Pickup For Sale

The Comanche isn’t typically found on every used car lot. Your search will likely involve a mix of online and specialized channels:

Online Marketplaces: Websites like eBay Motors, Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist, and AutoTrader Classics are primary hunting grounds. Set up search alerts for new listings.
Dedicated Forums & Clubs: The "Comanche Club" forum (ComancheClub.com) and NAXJA (North American XJ Association) forums often have classified sections where passionate owners sell their MJs. These are excellent places for detailed information and often well-maintained examples.
Specialized Classic/Off-Road Dealers: Some smaller dealerships specialize in vintage 4x4s and might occasionally have a Comanche. Expect higher prices, but potentially better reconditioned vehicles.
Local Classifieds & Word of Mouth: Don’t underestimate old-school methods. Sometimes the best deals are found through local classifieds, community bulletin boards, or simply by spreading the word among fellow enthusiasts.
Auctions: Online and live auctions can be a source, but often come with more risk as detailed inspections might be limited.

The Buying Process: Tips for a Smooth Transaction

Once you’ve found a potential candidate, a structured approach to the buying process is crucial.

Research & Set a Budget: Understand the market value for different conditions and configurations. Factor in potential repair costs and post-purchase maintenance.
Thorough Inspection: Beyond the rust check, inspect the engine bay for fluid leaks, listen for strange noises during startup, check all lights and electrical components. Get underneath to examine suspension components, axles, and the exhaust system.
Professional Pre-Purchase Inspection (PPI): If you’re serious, especially for an out-of-state vehicle, invest in a PPI by a trusted independent mechanic specializing in Jeeps or older vehicles. This can uncover hidden issues.
Test Drive: Pay attention to steering feel, brake performance, transmission shifts, and any unusual vibrations or noises. Test all 4WD modes. Drive it on varying terrain if possible.
Negotiation: Be prepared to negotiate. Use any identified issues as leverage. Don’t be afraid to walk away if the seller is unwilling to budge on price or if red flags emerge.
Paperwork: Ensure the title is clean and matches the VIN on the vehicle. Get a detailed bill of sale. Understand your state’s requirements for title transfer and registration.
Post-Purchase Plan: Even a well-maintained Comanche will benefit from immediate fluid changes (engine, transmission, differentials), a tune-up, and a thorough inspection of brakes and tires.

Common Issues and Potential Solutions

While rugged, Comanches are not immune to age-related wear. Knowing common issues can help in inspection and future maintenance.

Rust: As mentioned, the biggest threat. Prevention is key (rustproofing). Repairs can range from patch panels to full frame section replacement.
Electrical Gremlins: Older wiring harnesses can develop issues. Common problems include intermittent gauges, flaky interior lights, and starting issues. Often related to poor grounds or corroded connections.
Sagging Leaf Springs: The rear leaf springs are prone to sagging over time, especially if the truck has hauled heavy loads. Aftermarket leaf springs or an "add-a-leaf" kit are common solutions.
Vacuum Leaks: Can cause rough idling, poor performance, and check engine lights. Inspect vacuum lines, especially around the intake manifold and brake booster.
Cooling System: The 4.0L runs warm. Overheating can damage the engine. Check for leaks, ensure the radiator is clean, and consider upgrading to an aluminum radiator or a higher-flow water pump.
Parts Availability: Good news! Because it shares so many components with the highly popular XJ Cherokee, parts for the Comanche are surprisingly easy to find, both new aftermarket and used OEM.

Customization and Upgrades

The Comanche is a blank canvas for personalization. Popular upgrades include:

Suspension Lifts: Ranging from mild 2-inch lifts for tire clearance to extreme 6+ inch lifts for serious off-roading.
Larger Tires: To improve off-road traction and aesthetic appeal.
Aftermarket Bumpers & Armor: For improved approach/departure angles, winch mounting, and body protection.
Engine Performance Mods: Cold air intakes, exhaust systems, and sometimes even superchargers or turbo kits for more power.
Interior Upgrades: Modern stereo systems, comfortable seats from newer Jeeps, or custom upholstery.

Jeep Cherokee Pickup (Comanche) Estimated Price Guide

Please note that these are approximate ranges and actual prices will vary significantly based on location, seller, specific condition, modifications, and market demand.

Condition Category	Drivetrain	Engine	Bed Length	Mileage Range	Estimated Price Range (USD)	Notes
Poor/Parts	2WD/4WD	Any	Any	High	$1,000 – $3,000	Significant rust, major mechanical issues, non-running.
Fair/Project	2WD/4WD	Any	Any	High	$3,000 – $7,000	Runs/drives but needs significant work (body, engine, transmission).
Good Driver	2WD/4WD	4.0L	Any	Medium-High	$7,000 – $12,000	Solid mechanically, minor rust, decent interior, usable as-is.
Excellent/Restored	4WD	4.0L	Short/Long	Low-Medium	$12,000 – $25,000+	Minimal rust, well-maintained/restored, clean interior, desirable trim.
Collector Grade	4WD	4.0L	Short	Very Low	$25,000 – $40,000+	Original, unmolested, show-quality, rare trim/options.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q1: Is the Jeep Comanche reliable?
A1: Yes, especially models equipped with the 4.0L inline-six engine. This engine is renowned for its durability and longevity. Regular maintenance is key to its continued reliability.

Q2: Are parts for the Comanche hard to find?
A2: Surprisingly, no. Since the Comanche shares most of its components from the cab forward with the incredibly popular XJ Cherokee, mechanical and body parts are readily available from aftermarket suppliers and junkyards. Specific bed and taillight parts are rarer but not impossible to find.

Q3: What’s the main difference between a Jeep Comanche and a Cherokee?
A3: The fundamental difference is the rear section. The Cherokee is an SUV with an enclosed cargo area, while the Comanche is a pickup truck with an open bed, although they share the same unibody front end and drivetrain options.

Q4: What’s a good price to pay for a Jeep Comanche?
A4: Prices vary widely based on condition, mileage, drivetrain (2WD vs. 4WD), engine (4.0L is more desirable), and trim level. Expect to pay anywhere from $3,000 for a running project to $15,000+ for a well-maintained or restored example.

Q5: Can a Jeep Comanche be used as a daily driver?
A5: Absolutely. Many owners use their Comanches as daily drivers. Their compact size, reliable 4.0L engine, and decent fuel economy (for a vintage truck) make them practical for everyday use, provided the vehicle is in good mechanical condition.

Q6: Is a Jeep Comanche a good investment?
A6: For well-preserved, low-mileage, or professionally restored examples, the Comanche is certainly appreciating in value and can be a good investment. For higher mileage or project trucks, the "investment" is more about the enjoyment of ownership and the satisfaction of bringing it back to life.

Conclusion

The Jeep Cherokee Pickup, the venerable Comanche MJ, stands as a testament to Jeep’s enduring legacy of rugged utility and adventurous spirit. Acquiring one is more than just buying a used truck; it’s investing in a piece of automotive history that offers a unique blend of practicality, off-road prowess, and classic appeal. While the search may require patience and a keen eye for detail, particularly regarding rust and maintenance, the reward of owning and driving this distinctive vehicle is immeasurable. With proper care, a Comanche can provide years of reliable service, adventure, and turn heads wherever it goes. Embrace the journey, do your homework, and you might just find your perfect piece of Jeep lore for sale.